Colombia: Where Good Drugs Thrive
Colombia today is not the Colombia of mainstream Hollywood. Once a country ravaged by domestic insecurity whose images of terror were exported to the rest of the world, the journey of Colombia over the past decade to its current economic, political, and social stability are a role model for Latin America and a reminder to all that Colombia is back. Colombia stands at the dawn of the new decade with the worst of its history behind it and poised for a peaceful transition of presidential power. President Álvaro Uribe’s successor inherits a safer security environment; a robust economy that averaged over 5% growth from 2002-2007; a national health system covering 93% of Colombians; and the fourth largest pharmaceutical market in Latin America. A gateway to South or Central America depending on which way you face, the best place in Latin America to do business according to the World Bank, and with competitive national and multinational pharmaceutical laboratories accessing one of Latin America’s best talent pools, the script on Colombia is being rewritten in ways no one imagined possible just ten years ago.
Progress from the peril
Like most economic sectors, pharmaceuticals have reaped the benefits of enhanced domestic security. The strength of Colombia’s resurgence is best measured by the profundity of its crisis. For decades Colombia was engulfed in a conflict between government forces and insurgents who funded their war through the trade in illicit narcotics. The historical roots of the conflict stem from a complex disparity of political and economic resources spread amongst social classes, with the worst of the crisis peaking in the late 1990s.
In 2002 newly-elected President Álvaro Uribe made domestic security his #1 priority. American aid and a wealth tax that committed over 70% of revenues to defense led to the disarmament of thousands of left-wing guerrillas and right-wing paramilitaries. Better security, an export-oriented growth strategy, and high commodity prices boosted economic growth. While the economy slightly contracted .2% last year, projections are for a quick rebound to 2.5% growth in 2010. Violence and insurgency threats still remain, but the confluence of reforms rejuvenated the business landscape in Colombia.
As Virgilio Barco, Executive Director of Invest in Bogotá, explains, “President Uribe’s focus on security was the beginning of everything. Since then his committed team has worked to improve the business climate. Colombia’s consistently high position on the various business rankings is a testament to this dedication; it reflects how deep the crisis was and the type of leadership present over the past decade.”
Pharma in a resurgent environment
Because of security concerns and globalization trends that consolidated production around the world, dozens of multinational (MNC) pharmaceutical companies closed their Colombian manufacturing plants. Today only a handful of MNCs operate their own plants, importing over 95% of their medicines and shifting mainly to a commercialization and marketing model.
“In their departure,” Barco adds, “they left an industry know-how. Colombia’s human resources in the medical and pharmaceutical field are renowned throughout Latin America. Many Colombian pharmaceutical companies purchased the plants of those who left and have developed home-grown operations. They are strong, sizeable, and expanding in Latin America.”
The supply of over 60% of pharmaceutical companies being local producers mixed with the demand created by expanding health insurance coverage makes Colombia a predominantly generics market. “The average price of generics is one of the lowest in Latin America,” says Alberto Bravo Borda, Executive President of Colombia’s National Association of Local Laboratories (ASINFAR). “This is because of strong competition that drives prices down. With the expansion of healthcare, insurance companies are now covering the greatest part of the private market. This has led to more prescriptions and a growth in units.”
Nevertheless, MNCs’ success in the $2.2 billion Colombian pharmaceutical market still looms large. A small cluster of foreign MNCs provide close to 45% of market value with a plethora of local laboratories covering the rest.
Spending nearly 8% of its gross domestic product on healthcare and having the third largest population in Latin America with 45 million people, the fiscal and structural indicators suggest a promising pharmaceutical environment. Industry growth – 11% in 2008 and 7% in 2009 – is mainly driven by the institutional market. The high volume of generics that Borda referred to contributed to a 9% decline in retail market value last year despite increasing 3% in units. The institutional line, however, has posted a robust 32% compound annual growth (CAGR) over the last five years with a further 16% projected for the next three to five years.
As expected, MNCs vie for the pole position in the institutional line with their research-based products for rare, infectious, and chronic diseases. Local laboratories, meanwhile, remain committed to their tradition of generics that has branded success in the retail market. But the impressive growth of the institutional market has also drawn their attention. Mario Morales Moreno, President of Genfar, the leading retail units seller, refers to the institutional line as “a key growth sector” and is keen to increase institutional sales from its current 25% of portfolio value.
A new challenge confronts Colombia furthering an interest in the institutional line. The budgetary shortfalls of the national health system and the ensuing Social Emergency Crisis (SEC) declared in December strengthen an emphasis on cost-competitive products. More than a chance to provide cost-efficient medicines, the SEC is an opportunity to prove that Colombia’s 20-year-old healthcare reforms are still the optimal means to achieve the national dream of universal coverage. A dream nearly achieved.
A Dream Nearly Acheived
Colombia’s healthcare system is governed by The Law 100 of 1993 designed to provide universal healthcare access through a system of managed competition of providers. Seventeen million Colombians under formal employment finance their healthcare through a 12% income tax and collectively form what is referred to as the “contributory regime.” Another 24 million citizens who are unemployed or live below the poverty line receive subsidized healthcare. All citizens are entitled to a portfolio of medicines and treatments issued by the Ministry of Social Protection called the Obligatory Health Plan (POS).
A total of 63 public and private health promoting entities (EPSs) administer healthcare with government compensated risk-adjusted premiums for every individual covered. Because Colombia mandates a strict benefit package of primary and preventative care from each EPS, competition derives from quality, not price, of services offered.
Under this structure and guided by the principles of universal coverage; equity in benefits regardless of contribution value; free choice to select a healthcare provider; and timeliness in receiving services, health coverage in Colombia has expanded from under 25% of the population in 1993 to 93% today. “Very few countries can have such an effective system,” asserts Francisco de Paul Gómez, Executive President of the Colombian Association of Research-based Pharmaceutical Laboratories (AFIDRO). “Regardless of differing opinions, access to healthcare is a real fact which brings us closer to the expectation of a general insurance with universal coverage. This has substantially changed the behavior of the pharmaceutical market.”
Too much of a good thing
Ironically, the impressive 93% coverage rate has also indirectly contributed to the stress of the system. Because access to healthcare is listed as a constitutional right, many patients sue healthcare providers for refusing to cover certain treatments not included in the POS. From 2006-2008 there were more than 346,400 lawsuits, with the courts usually ruling in favor of the patients.
The result has been an explosion in costs for the government and EPSs. In December 2009, nine of the fifteen largest EPSs said they were close to bankruptcy. Finance Minister Oscar Zuluaga estimated that $400 million would be needed to save the system.
In an immediate response to the crisis President Uribe declared a social emergency and issued 16 decrees that bypassed legislative approval. Decrees 128 and 131 generated the most controversy. Decree 128 mandated patients to finance treatments not included in the POS using personal savings or retirement funds. Decree 131 ruled that doctors who prescribed non-POS medicines could be fined up to $13,000. Because of the widespread protests that these decrees triggered, the government repealed the $13,000 fine and limited out-of-pocket expenses to only the upper class. A final list of an updated POS will be issued in June.
Business as usual, innovation as always
While the ending remains unwritten on the SEC, the successful business of innovation carries on as usual for MNCs in Colombia. Colombia has proven to be a reliable market for MNCs with AFIDRO companies growing on 11-12% average during the years of the financial crisis. As Rolf E. Hoenger, General Director of Productos Roche S.A., light-heartedly comments, “you cannot call 12% growth a crisis.” Roche in fact grew by 25% in Colombia in 2009 on the backs of its specialized products in the institutional market that constitute 80% of their business. With 55% of their portfolio in oncology and majority of the remaining 45% dedicated to other specialized treatments such as rheumatoid arthritis and cystic fibrosis, Roche’s niche in unique biologicals will continue to drive its growth towards Hoenger’s goal of double its current market share within the next three years.
Personifying innovation and niche market penetration is Genzyme de Colombia S.A. A newcomer to Colombia in 2002, Genzyme’s growth to the tune of 20% in 2009, 46% in 2008, and 25% CAGR over the past five years is attributed in part to the typical exponential growth of a new company but also to their specialized offering of rare and orphan diseases medicines. Boasting a product portfolio for lysosomal disorders, renal infections, oncology, and biosurgery, Claudia Varela, General Manager for Peru, Ecuador & Colombia, takes special pride in the pioneer role that Genzyme has adopted through its attention for neglected patients. “It is the nature of Genzyme to work with niche patients in rare disorders,” says Varela. Particular inroads have been made in identifying patients and meeting the medical needs for lysosomal diseases such as Mucopolysaccharidosis (MPS). Genzyme has actively been identifying MPS I patients in Colombia and through variations in rare diseases in developing countries are now discovering patients of MPS Types II & VI.
Concurring with the reliability of Colombia is GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) Colombia. In 2008 GSK Corporate outlined strategic priorities centred on “more growth, less risk” with a special emphasis on emerging markets. According to Michael Sean Reilly, GSK Colombia’s General Manager for Pharmaceuticals, Colombia fits this strategy being classified as both a growth and emerging market. “Latin America has a mix between stable and volatile, short term high-profit markets. Colombia is a stable market that is not expected to grow excessively over the next few years. You can count on a relative 5-10% growth, but you are not going to lose money. The risk analysis for Colombia is normally a lot less than what you see for Venezuela or Argentina which experience frequent big shifts in the market and the economy.”
GSK’s strategy to fuel growth in this low-risk environment is to diversify the traditional business model and adapt to local market opportunities. Rather than relying on one or two blockbusters, the goal is to have many medium-sized products in different areas. “GSK before was very oriented towards internal intellectual property (IP) products. Now we are looking for local growth opportunities from in-licensing products from European or Asian companies that do not exist here in Colombia; local growth opportunities from vaccines; and opportunities from alliances with companies from China and India. This is a new strategy for us.”
Gran Colombia anew
Colombia emerged as one of three sovereign countries following the collapse of Gran Colombia in 1830, along with Ecuador and Venezuela. At the end of the 19th Century the United States seized control of Panama, then a Colombian province, thus ending Colombia’s ruling engagements abroad.
Pharmaceutically speaking, conquest of neighboring countries is back on Colombia’s radar. Colombia’s geographic positioning as the gateway to both Central and South America, makes it natural for industrial sectors to have an abroad-oriented vision for nearby markets to penetrate. This is indeed the case for a multitude of local pharmaceutical companies competing domestically, but sharing equally great ambitions to bring a new Gran Colombia of pharmaceutical prowess to the neighboring markets of Central America and the Caribbean.
“When you have 54% of the market, how much higher can you get?” asks Emilio Sardi, Executive Vice-President of Tecnoquímicas, 15th in both sales and units in the 2009 retail market. “It is much easier to go to other markets which you can do with the right marketing technology. We can become very strong in Central America because they are markets of small countries that are not necessarily interesting for big multinationals. Our idea is to buy strong companies in each country and become a dominant player in the whole area.” Sardi’s strategy is similar to many other local companies: in the face of fierce competition domestically, penetrable and culturally similar foreign markets are just around the corner.
The regionalization of Tecnoquímicas was supported by the International Finance Corporation. “Their idea was for local companies to become regional. They wanted companies good at selling generics to expand abroad in order to help poor countries and fulfill the World Bank’s social commitment,” says Sardi. A $25 million equity investment helped finance Tecnoquímicas’ 2009 purchase of the El Salvadorian pharmaceutical company Teramed. Future similar acquisitions are in store for 2010 to bolster their regional presence.
Buy, conquer, and directly represent always remains an option for companies flush with cash. The more typical practice, however, has been penetration through a reliable chain of alliances and regional distributors. Farma de Colombia, fresh off its 50th anniversary in February, has leveraged strong relations with distributors in Panama to boost exports to 17% of its total revenue in 2009. “Panama is our gateway to the rest of Central America and the Caribbean,” says General Manager Mazen Makarem. “We sell them our products, offer marketing input, and they do everything from there. It is not necessarily Farma de Colombia being present in these markets; rather, it is the distributing companies themselves.”
With high quality standards set by INVIMA, Colombia’s regulatory agency for food and drugs, companies are in favorable positions to push exports abroad. One of Genfar’s slogans “A Multi-Latin company, 100% Colombian” speaks to its regional presence in 14 countries facilitated by its network of affiliates and strategic distribution partners.
Jorge E. Jiménez, founder of Biochem Farmaceútica and a self-described man “born in the pharmaceutical industry,” describes his market of interest to be “any regional country where we are not currently present.” With branded generics in antibiotics, antihistamines, flu and parasitic treatment, Biochem actively seeks distributing alliances to cover new regional markets. With over 40 years industry experience working for American, European, and now his own Colombian company, Jiménez drives Biochem with an expansion, yet, survivor mentality noting that “a company that does not grow is likely to disappear.”
Chalver Laboratories, founded in 1960 by Jesús Chacón, began manufacturing small products but was constantly driven by a mentality of growth. Purchase by purchase, Chalver expanded to its present-day structure of export and warehousing operations in 15 countries with over 380 commercial partners. “Our experience and market knowledge allows us to project ourselves as a company capable of growing consistently in the region with a broad scheme of products that are adjusted to each country’s needs,” describes Chacón. The first Colombian company to offer an alternative medicine for prostate cancer, combining polymer and peptide, Chalver’s delivery of high value and necessity products embodies the tendency of local generic producers to shape a cost-competitive environment. “Before our prostate cancer product the price for the original drug was around $500,” Chacón explains. “After our launch the price dropped to $120.”
Chalver is unique as a company that has pushed exports by basing itself within one of Colombia’s 69 Free Trade Zones (FTZs), an incentive which lowers their corporate tax by more than half of Colombia’s normal rate. The benefits of the FTZ’s systematized processes, storage, and transportation facilities, according to Chacón, allow Chalver “to provide better service and to become more efficient in a highly competitive market.”
“Home”work through alliances
According to Rodrigo Arcila Gómez, Executive Director of the National Business Association of Colombia (ANDI), 71% of pharmaceutical industry production supplies the domestic market. With Latin America’s third largest population, there is still plenty of business to take care of at home.
Colombia’s sizeable population, healthcare coverage, and unique epidemiological profile naturally make it an enticing market for foreign pharmaceutical companies. Farma de Colombia represents five companies from countries ranging from the US, Switzerland, Mexico, and Brazil. “Fifteen years ago, however,” comments Makarem, “our licenses exceeded our own products. The situation reversed because of mergers and acquisitions” that granted market access to synergized companies. When Makarem began as General Manager in 1999, Farma de Colombia lost its license agreement with newly merged Astra-Zeneca, costing them $8 million. After company soul-searching, Farma de Colombia emerged less reliant on licensing and determined to strengthen its own brand lines as it has done with Calcibon, the Colombian market leading calcium prescription, and Akatinol, a market share leader in Latin America for Alzheimer treatment. “With Colombia approaching universal coverage and with the tremendous reach of the population to healthcare, there is still an important private market which we focus very strongly on. The private sector is a good arena to build the brands that we value.”
The same trend of blockbuster M&As coupled with stricter INVIMA standards that forced companies out of the market produced opportunities for smaller players focused on low-incidence diseases. Created in 1999, General Manager Luis Gabriel González explains that Vesalius Pharma’s purpose was to represent foreign companies entering Colombia. González notes that “the Colombian market is permanently growing in units but decreasing in value” due to expanded health coverage which attracts many competitive suppliers. Rather than competing in the crowded generics market, Vesalius, “deals in closed markets with exclusive products manufactured by biotechnology companies that have no representation in the country.” Founded with a focus on tuberculosis, Vesalius has expanded its portfolio to over 150 products for orphan diseases, anaesthesia, intensive care, and oncology.
González’s logic for ambitious export growth is refreshingly simple: there is a world of business out there. Colombia represents only .26% of the global pharmaceutical market. There is a huge demand for rare disease treatment in the US, Mexico, and Brazil that Vesalius seeks to supply through strategic alliances. “The fundamental goal towards the future for Vesalius is to look for new alliances to cover Latin American market. We believe that Colombian market is a highly competitive and saturated one. The future of our company is in the rest of America,” he says.
A regional player at your service
The global contract research organization (CRO) market is set to grow 14% over the next three years to be a $35 billion industry by 2013 as companies seek to cut drug development costs through outsourced R&D. CROs offer pharmaceutical companies the chance to roll-over fixed research costs into lower variable costs and boost productivity by focusing on competitive advantages. Situated in the tropics, Colombia is an advantageous market for clinical trials because of its population size, diversity, and proximity to the US.
LatAm Clinical Trials capitalizes on these dynamics. As a niche CRO specialized in vaccine testing and infectious disease treatment, LatAm provides a one-stop shop for pharmaceutical companies looking for a regional contact. LatAm conducts Phase 1-4 testing and clinical trial management from project start to finish throughout Colombia, Panama, Costa Rica, Peru, and the Dominican Republic. “We have a tremendous knowledge of the cultural diversity of this region,” says Diana Valencia, LatAm’s Executive Director. Labeled by Valencia as an untapped region, Colombia, unlike Argentina and Brazil with their high volume of clinical research projects has “opportunities through new, untested subjects,” she explains. Additionally, “the therapeutical profiles of our subjects overlap with the same areas that are associated with the ten major causes of mortality in the US. Colombia, epidemiologically, behaves very similar to developed countries. We can also offer treatment and services in infectious diseases that are typically found in developing countries but are now emerging in the developed world.”
Taking The Responsible LEED
More than suppliers of drugs and medicines, Colombian pharmaceutical companies embrace their role as socially responsible agents of change.
Novartis, consistently atop industry rankings as one of the most ethical and socially responsible pharmaceutical companies, added a new dimension to its innovative identity when inaugurating in February its new nine-story office in downtown Bogotá as the first LEED-certified (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) building in Colombia. “I know that because of this building other buildings in this area, in this city, and in this country are going to follow the trend that we set,” says Maria Álvarez, General Manager of Novartis de Colombia. President Uribe, speaking at the inaugural ceremony, praised Novartis for its environmental stewardship and recognized the important contributions its work has on instilling investor confidence in Colombia. In industry and social responsibility, leadership and trendsetting is second nature for Novartis. Investing over $19 million in 123 clinical trials from 2007-2010, Novartis’ R&D penetrates cardiovascular, respiratory, and oncology areas in over 150 medical centers throughout Colombia. Furthermore, they were the first pharmaceutical company in Colombia to sign the United Nations Global Compact on socially responsible business practices. Promoting access to healthcare is a core pillar of Roche’s work in Colombia. The same applies to their inroads in social responsibility with Roche working side-by-side with patient associations to increase informed access to medicines. Hoenger explains that Roche “does extensive work in patient education to clarify questions a patient has about disease and treatments. As can be the case with institutions, doctors have very little time to explain detailed information to them. Our outreach is all about ensuring access to proper information about healthcare.”
A DifferentType of Risk
Proexport, the government agency for foreign investment and tourism promotion, launched a campaign inviting people to Colombia where “the only risk is wanting to stay.” Fifteen years ago the message of visiting Colombia, risk, and staying behind carried starkly different imagery. Visitors to Colombia today will find a safer atmosphere whose risk profile favors the country as a preferred investment destination. As Virgilio Barco explains, “Brazil and Mexico are the largest economies, but the panorama is shifting. Argentina is an attractive market but relative macroeconomic instability can worry investors. Chile is very stable, but small and with a high cost structure. Central American countries are very small and Venezuela is out of the question right now. Colombia is a very interesting third destination in Latin America because of its large market size and its quality of human resources.”
Colombia is lauded by pharmaceutical executives as a talent pool because of its strong level of education, work ethic, and professionalism. “When you ask an investor why they consider Colombia a trustworthy market, they will reply because of the strong workforce and excellent human resources,” asserts Rodrigo Arcila Gómez. “The country is riding a double wave of emerging market growth and improved domestic security,” adds GSK’s Reilly. “Colombia is a very resilient country with resilient people.” This resurgence earned Colombia the accolade as “the best place to do business” in Latin America by a World Bank Doing Business Report in November 2009.
Questions still surround the state of healthcare in Colombia as it navigates the transitions of the Social Emergency Crisis. POS reforms will usher in changes for new players, medicines, and technologies. National laboratories vehemently call for liberalizing intellectual property requirements to allow them to compete with cost-efficient medicines. MNCs believe that the future of the pharmaceutical industry rests with innovation, respect for its protection, and adherence to the principles of free market trade.
But with the future still unwritten the current pieces are in play for the Colombian pharmaceutical industry to continue its success of the past several years. At home, scientific and marketing innovations enhance the medicines that 93% of Colombians have access to. A talented workforce is engaged in the sustainable and responsible development of its industry and community. Abroad, new alliances promote exports and bring innovative medicines into the country. Long stereotyped for its violence and lawlessness, the pharmaceutical industry is poised to put Colombia on the map for all the right reasons.
colombia, market, companies, pharmaceutical, growth, healthcare, america, latin, colombian, industry, medicines, patients, president, alliances, mncs, laboratories, national, health, generics, diseases, risk